LITERATURE REVIEW ON WESTERN MORAL GEOGRAPHY STUDIES: A CONTRAST BASED ON CITESPACE AND MANUAL RETRIEVAL
ZHU Xuan1, SU Ti-ya2
1. School of Tourism, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai 200234, China;
2. School of Environmental and Geographical Sciences, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai 200234, China
摘要 利用CiteSpace软件对Web of Science数据库中道德地理相关文献进行共被引分析和关键词共现分析，对比人工检索和文献阅读的结果，对西方道德地理的研究进展进行系统梳理评述。研究结论：①对高中心性和高突现性文献的研究发现，关怀、伦理、道德、责任等关键词和远距离的关怀与责任、道德经济与道德消费、地方政治中的不平等与权利问题等三大研究主题构成了道德地理研究的一大理路，侧重阐释“道德的地理”；②早期道德地理著名学者Sack的系列论著并未能成为高引文献，原因一在于其理论的高度抽象和隐晦难解，二在于他试图建构普适的空间道德评判标准，因而很难被实证主义研究者们理解和追随，但他构建的“二元道德论”强调“地理的道德”，是道德地理研究的另一条理路，可以为评判地方道德提供了全面、明确而实用的标准，值得被后续研究发展和深化；③研究同时揭示：囿于数据库数据和技术手段的限制，单纯依靠文献分析软件的研究方式可能会出现偏差，高质量的人工检索阅读仍是文献研究的必然路径。
Abstract：This paper provides a systematic review on Western moral geography research. The review is started by applying CiteSpace software to conduct literature cocitation analysis and keyword copresentation analysis for literature searched in the Web of Science database. Analysis of the results reveals that care, ethics, morality, and responsibility are the main topics in the high centrality literature and high citation bursts literature; sociology, economics, and political science are integrated into research of moral geography, discussing issues of ‘care and responsibility at a distance’, ‘moral economy and moral consumption’, and ‘inequality and rights in local politics’. The review is followed by manual retrieval and snowball readings from the references of high centrality and high citation bursts literature. Manual retrieval and snowball readings implies that the classical theories proposed by Sack, an eminent scholar specializing on early moral geography, have not been highly cited for two reasons:1) his articles are highly abstract and obscure, which made it very hard to understand, and 2) he attempts to make universal moral criteria for any place, restraining the empirical studies to follow as they would be easily accused of leaving the "politically correct" track.
朱璇, 苏提雅. 西方道德地理研究述评——基于CiteSpace和人工检索的对比分析[J]. 人文地理, 2021, 36(4): 9-20.
ZHU Xuan, SU Ti-ya. LITERATURE REVIEW ON WESTERN MORAL GEOGRAPHY STUDIES: A CONTRAST BASED ON CITESPACE AND MANUAL RETRIEVAL. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY, 2021, 36(4): 9-20.
Lawson V. Geographies of care and responsibility[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2007,97(1):1-11.
[2]
庄晓平,尹书华,朱竑.旅游发展对古村落村民公民性建构的影响——以开平古碉楼群为例[J].地理学报,2018,73(8):1571-1585.[Zhuang Xiaoping, Yin Shuhua, Zhu Hong. The impact of tourism development on the construction of citizenship for ancient village residents in rural China:The case study of Kaiping Diaolou Complex[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2018,73(8):1571-1585.]
[3]
Harman J R, Harrington J A, Cerveny R S. Balancing scientific and ethical values in environmental science[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1998,88(2):277-286.
[4]
Smith D M. Geography and ethics:How far should we go?[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 1999,23(1):119-125.
[5]
Driver F. Moral geographies:Social science and the urban environment in mid 19th century England[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 1988,13(3):275-287.
[6]
Matless D. Moral Geography in Broadland[J]. Ecumene, 1994,1(2):127-155.
[7]
Matless D. Moral geographies of English landscape[J]. Landscape Research, 1997,22(2):141-155.
[8]
Matless D. Moral geographies[M]//Gregory G, Johnston R, Pratt G, et al. The Dictionary of Human Geography (5th Edition). Singapore:Wiley-Blackwell, 2009:478.
[9]
Jackson P. Social disorganization and moral order in the city[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 1984,9(2):168-180.
[10]
Jackson P, Smith S J. Exploring Social Geography[M]. London:Allen & Unwin, 1984:66.
[11]
Jackson P. Maps of Meaning:An Introduction to Cultural Geography[M]. London:Unwin Hyman,1989:100.
[12]
Ley D. Co-operative housing as a moral landscape:Re-examining ‘the postmodern city’[M]//Duncan J, Ley D. Place/Culture/Representation. London:Routledge, 1993:128-148.
[13]
Holmes A P, Grimwood B S R, King L J. Creating an indigenized visitor code of conduct:The development of Denesoline self-determination for sustainable tourism[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2016,24(8/9):1177-1193.
[14]
Ogborn M, Philo C. Soldiers, sailors and moral locations in nineteenth-century Portsmouth[J]. Area, 1994,26(3):221-231.
[15]
Proctor J D. Whose nature? The contested moral terrain of ancient forests[M]//Cronon W. Uncommon Ground:Rethinking the Human Place in Nature. New York:W.W. Norton, 1995:269-297.
[16]
Smith D M. Geography and moral philosophy:Some common ground[J]. Philosophy & Geography, 1998,1(1):7-33.
[17]
Massey D. Geographies of responsibility[J]. Geografiska Annaler:Series B, Human Geography, 2004,86(1):5-18.
[18]
Popke J. Geography and ethics:Everyday mediations through care and consumption[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2006,30(4):504-512.
[19]
Popke J. Geography and ethics:Spaces of cosmopolitan responsibility[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2007,31(4):509-518.
[20]
Smith D M. Moral Geographies:Ethics in a World of Difference[M]. Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press, 2000:1-235.
[21]
Harvey D. Cosmopolitanism and the Geographies of Freedom[M]. New York:Columbia University Press, 2009:1-283.
[22]
Brock G. Does obligation diminish with distance?[J]. Ethics, Place and Environment, 2005,8(1):3-20.
[23]
Cloke P. Deliver us from evil? Prospects for living ethically and acting politically in human geography[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2002,26(5):587-604.
[24]
Olson E, Sayer A. Radical geography and its critical standpoints:Embracing the Normative[J]. Antipode, 2009,41(1):180-198.
[25]
Barnett C, Cloke P, Clarke M, et al. Consuming ethics:Articulating the subjects and spaces of ethical consumption[J]. Antipode, 2005, 37(1):23-45.
[26]
Jackson P, Ward N, Russell P. Moral economies of food and geographies of responsibility[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2009,34(1):12-24.
[27]
Young I M. From guilt to solidarity:Sweatshops and political responsibility[J]. Dissent, 2003,50(2):39-44.
[28]
Kelly P. The geographies and politics of globalization[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 1999,23(3):379-400.
[29]
Parr H, Philo C. Social geographies of rural mental health:Summary report[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2003,4(4):471-488.
[30]
Ho E, Boyle M, Yeoh B. Recasting diaspora strategies through feminist care ethics[J]. Geoforum, 2015,59(1):206-214.
[31]
Buller H. Animal geographies III:Ethics[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2015,40(3):422-430.
[32]
Gillespie K, Lawson V. ‘My Dog is My Home’:Multispecies care and poverty politics in Los Angeles, California and Austin, Texas[J]. Gender, Place & Culture, 2017,24(6):774-793.
[33]
Connoll C. ‘A place for everything’:Moral landscapes of ‘swiftlet farming’ in George Town, Malaysia[J]. Geoforum, 2016,77(1):182-191.
[34]
Taylor C S, Carter J. Care in the contested geographies of DolphinAssisted Therapy[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2020,21(1):64-85.
[35]
Lejano R, Funderburg R. Geographies of risk, the regulatory state, and the ethic of care[J]. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2016,106(5):1097-1113.
[36]
Bailey I. Spatializing climate justice:Justice claim making and carbon pricing controversies in Australia[J]. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2017,107(5):1128-1143.
[37]
Dunnett O. Contested landscapes:The moral geographies of light pollution in Britain[J]. Cultural Geographies, 2015,22(4):619-636.
[38]
Whitehead M. From moral space to the morality of scale:The case of the sustainable region[J]. Ethics Place & Environment, 2003, 6(3):235-257.
[39]
Smith A. The Theory of Moral Sentiments[M]. Beijing:The Commercial Press, 2015:7-9.
[40]
Polanyi K. The Great Transformation[M]. Frankfurt:Suhrkamp, 1978:45-80.
[41]
Thompson E P. The moral economy of english crowd in the 18th century[J]. Past and Present, 1971,50(1):76-136.
[42]
Sayer A. Moral economy and political economy[J]. Studies in Political Economy:A Socialist Review, 2000,61(1):79-103.
[43]
梁文静.公益组织的道德经济——以美国中镇仁人舍为个案[J]. 青海民族研究,2017,28(2):28-32.[Liang Wenjing. Moral economy of nonprofit organizations:The case of middletown habitat for humanity, U.S.A.[J]. Qinghai Journal of Ethnology, 2017,28(2):28-32.]
[44]
DuPuis E M, Goodman D. Should we go ‘home’ to eat? Toward a reflexive politics of localism[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 2005,21(3):359-372.
[45]
Lee R. Shelter from the storm? Geographies of regard in the worlds of horticultural consumption and production[J]. Geoforum, 2000, 31(2):137-157.
[46]
Jackson P. Consumption and identity:The cultural politics of shopping[J]. European Planning Studies, 1999,7(1):25-39.
[47]
Hartwick E. Towards a geographical politics of consumption[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2000,32(7):1177-1192.
[48]
Strong C. Features contributing to the growth of ethical consumerism-a preliminary investigation[J]. Marketing Intelligence and Planning, 1996,14(5):5-13.
[49]
Doherty B, Smith A, Parker S. Fair Trade market creation and marketing in the Global South[J]. Geoforum, 2015,67(1):158-171.
[50]
Johnston R J. A Question of Place:Exploring the Practice of Human Geography[M]. Oxford:Blackwell, 1991:1-37.
[51]
刘云刚.中国政治地理学研究展望[J].人文地理,2009,24(2):12-16, 28.[Liu Yungang. A Research perspective on Chinese political geography[J]. Human Geography, 2009,24(2):12-16,28.]
[52]
刘云刚,安宁,王丰龙.中国政治地理学的学术谱系[J].地理学报, 2018,73(12):2269-2281.[Liu Yungang, An Ning, Wang Fenglong. The outline and genealogy of Chinese political geography[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2018,73(12):2269-2281.]
[53]
Katz C. On the grounds of globalization:A topography for feminist political engagement[J]. Signs, 2001,26(4):1213-1234.
[54]
McDowell L. Work, workfare, work/life balance and an ethic of care[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2004,28(2):145-163.
[55]
Mackintosh P G, Forsberg C R. Performing the lodge:Masonry, masculinity, and nineteenth-century North American moral geography[J]. Journal of Historical Geography, 2009,35(3):451-472.
[56]
Gökarksel B, Secor A J. Devout Muslim masculinities:The moral geographies and everyday practices of being men in Turkey[J]. Gender, Place & Culture, 2017,24(3):381-402.
[57]
Amin A. Ethnicity and the multicultural city:Living with diversity[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2002,34(6):959-980.
[58]
Low N, Gleeson B. Geography, justice and the limits of rights[M]//Proctor J D, Smith D M. Geography and Ethics:Journeys in a Moral Terrain. London:Routledge Press, 1999:30-44.
[59]
Sack R D. Homo Geographicus[M]. London:John Hopkins University Press, 1997:1-292.
[60]
Sack R D. A sketch of a geographic theory of morality[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1999,89(1):26-44.
[61]
Sack R D. The geographic problematic:Empirical issues[J]. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift-Norwegian Journal of Geography, 2001, 55(1):107-116.
[62]
Sack R D. The geographic problematic:Moral issues[J]. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift-Norwegian Journal of Geography, 2001,55(3):117-125.
[63]
Sack R D. A Geographical Guide to the Real and the Good[M]. London:Taylor & Francis, 2003:3-40.
[64]
Cutchin M P. Ethics and geography:Continuity and emerging syntheses[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2002,26(5):656-664.
[65]
Pow C P. ‘Good’ and ‘Real’ places:A geographical-moral critique of territorial place-making[J]. Geografiska Annaler Series B:Human Geography, 2009,91(2):91-105.
[66]
Barnett C. Geography and ethics III:From moral geographies to geographies of worth[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2013,38(1):151-160.
[67]
成志芬,周尚意,张宝秀. "乡愁"研究的文化地理学视角[J].北京联合大学学报(人文社会科学版),2015,13(4):64-70.[Cheng Zhifen, Zhou Shangyi, Zhang Baoxiu. The perspectives of cultural geography on "nostalgia" research[J]. Journal of Beijing Union University (Humanities and Social Sciences), 2015,13(4):64-70.]
[68]
周尚意,成志芬.关于"乡愁"的空间道德和地方道德评价[J].人文地理,2015,30(6):1-6.[Zhou Shangyi, Cheng Zhifen. On the morality of nostalgia[J]. Human Geography, 2015,30(6):1-6.]
[69]
周尚意.旅游与空间道德碰撞[J].旅游学刊,2017,32(4):1-2.[Zhou Shangyi. Tourism and morality[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2017,32(4):1-2.]
[70]
周尚意,许伟麟,成志芬.胡同乡愁的空间道德与地方道德评价——以北京西四地区为例[J].当代中国价值观研究,2017,2(1):95-101.[Zhou Shangyi, Xu Weilin, Cheng Zhifen. On the morality of nostalgia:A case study of Xisi Area in Beijing[J]. Chinese Journal of Contemporary Values, 2017,2(1):95-101.]
